Don’t Ignore Your Google SEO Efforts in Favour of AI Visibility
In short
Chasing AI visibility at the expense of Google is a mistake: traffic from AI tools is still very low and Google remains the main source of organic traffic and leads for most websites. Users move between AI tools, social media and Google before they buy, so the channels complement each other, and the work Google rewards also improves how AI tools see you.

The SEO industry is going through quite a monumental shift at the moment brought about by the increasing use of LLMs, such as ChatGPT and Gemini when searching for information, products and services. Businesses we speak to are all very keen to “rank” in AI outputs, sometimes over and above Google search results.
This is a big mistake. The traffic from AI tools is still very very low. By far, the highest level of organic traffic is still, by far, from Google. You really need to look at these traffic sources as complementary instead of as totally separate strategies.
Although Google traffic has been in decline, as I’ve discussed in previous insights here, it is still the main organic traffic and lead source for most of the websites that we work with and own.
We’ve seen this before
What is happening at the moment reminds me of when social media started to become mainstream and in a knee jerk reaction, Google even launched its own social media platform, Google+. This was a complete disaster. Google was worried that users would use social media to search for products and services and this would negatively impact its core service and business. It didn’t happen, Google search kept growing.
Yes, users do use social media to search for things, but they also still use Google. Google is also more trusted (relatively), and when making purchasing decisions, users will combine seeing something on social media, to checking reviews on Google, carry out additional research and then maybe finally buy something.
These services actually all complement each other which is why it’s important for businesses to be visible across multiple platforms. User behaviour is far from linear and conversions happen over time instead of instantly.
AI tools still lean on search
What is happening now with AI is the same. I find myself talking to Claude or Gemini, and then following that up with a search on Google for verification or to dig deeper. If you notice when you prompt an LLM, it will often say “Searching the web…”. The tools are just doing that job for you and making some sense of the search results. We’re not at that stage where we want these tools making all of these decisions for us… yet!
Keep investing in Google
Therefore, it’s still important to focus on your Google optimisation efforts. They will ultimately also positively affect your visibility in AI tools. The fundamentals still matter and human effort is critical. Don’t go for increased AI visibility, go for what these systems and Google reward… effort and trust!