Why Your Google Search Traffic Is Declining and What to Do About It
In short
Organic traffic from Google is falling for most websites because AI Overviews and AI Mode answer questions on the results page, more people search with AI tools, the results are busier and rankings are more personalised. Start by working out which traffic you actually lost and whether it converted, then check how the results for your key terms have changed and make your money pages genuinely excellent.

If you’ve been online for the past few years, and enjoying some traffic from Google, the chances are that when you compare the level of your organic traffic to that of last year’s, traffic will appear to have taken quite a hit, even if you haven’t really changed much on your website or done anything suspect to trigger some sort of ranking penalty.
Why your traffic is falling
This loss in traffic is quite normal for a number of reasons.
- Google is increasingly showing AI Overviews in the search results, meaning that users can find answers to their questions directly from Google, without having to click through to any websites. The option of also searching using AI Mode further impacts the problem.
- Users are increasingly turning to AI tools to search, instead of using Google, such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity. These tools, similar to AI Overviews, give very complete answers and give users less need to click through to websites.
- The search results themselves are getting busier. Google is showing bigger and more prominent ad blocks, as it prioritises its main revenue source, and then there are image results, “people also ask”, “people also search for”, forums and discussions and so much more.
- Search results are increasingly personalised and localised. If you search from your phone, your computer, from different locations and at different times of the day… you’ll get a slightly different set of results. There is little ranking stability as there are just too many factors that come into generating the results.
This may all make it look like we may as well throw in the towel and just pay for (increasingly expensive) Google ads. But there is hope…
What to do now
The first thing is understanding what traffic you have actually lost. Was it useful traffic? Did it convert? What is the type of traffic that you actually want?
For example, Google generally serves up AI Overviews for informational queries. This type of traffic generally used to go to blog pages or resource pages. This type of traffic isn’t generally great traffic and can in most cases convert at a very low level.
The second thing is to review if the search results have changed for your key search terms. What is Google prioritising now? What does AI Mode focus the user on (this is a great insight into the search intent)? Do your pages align with the top-ranking pages?
The third thing is to review your key (money) pages. Be honest, are they really good? Do they really get across why someone should contact you or buy from you? Does your experience, expertise, authority and trust (EEAT) come across clearly? Be critical and if you need further advice, ask Gemini to give you some honest feedback too, even if it hurts to hear it!
Less is more
This is a time when less is more. Think about having fewer pages that are absolutely brilliant. Trying to grow the website using ChatGPT generated content is possibly one of the worst strategies you can implement today, although I see it every day. Traffic is declining, focus on the user and you will be rewarded for putting the user first.